Hooray for the Urban Living Index: A new evidence base to help urban planners & policy makers

Wednesday, December 23, 2015

The co-authors of the newly developed Urban Living Index – The Urban Taskforce and McCrindle Research – rightly state that the challenge in planning for Sydney’s future is to ensure that population growth does not compromise its “world-beating lifestyle”. By tracking five key categories that produce a measure of liveability in a city, the Index is a great first step in developing an evidence base to monitoring changes as the Sydney metropolitan area as it grows – both outwards and upwards.

A key theme in most media reporting about the Index is that upwards growth – through increased residential density – is the way to ensure high levels of amenity and accessibility are maintained as Sydney grows, and that a reliance on outwards expansion may compromise such liveability standards. Although the Index broadly shows that denser residential areas rate highly from a liveability perspective, we need to dig a bit deeper to understand what it is about these areas that make them liveable. It is not just a case of these highly rated areas being dense, which is actually just a relative measure of compactness. There are many more factors at play than compactness in making a place liveable and sustainable.

The structure of the overall city, with its public transport and road network and its layout of employment and retail locations, influences transport choice more than most other factors. At the local level, good walking and cycling connectivity to local shopping and public transport services is the key to how we move around. Of course, there is also the influence that individual behaviours, intentions and beliefs have on how a community might inhabit and use places and spaces. Density also plays a role, especially population density, as this helps underpin social and economic sustainability in local areas. But density is not the end game – far from it.

For example, the Index shows that Marrickville has a relatively low high density component for an inner city area (40%) but a very high liveability ranking. On the other hand, Woollahra has a higher high density component (50%) but a relatively low liveability ranking for an inner urban area. If one interrogates the rankings, you’ll see that Marrickville ranks highest for accessibility (which considers the factors I mention above), whereas Woollahra has a relatively low ranking for accessibility. This example, and there are many others across the metropolitan region, shows that higher density areas do not necessarily guarantee higher levels of accessibility.

The upshot of policy makers and planners thinking that increased density inevitably produces more liveable and sustainable urban areas has resulted in, until recently, a saturation of multi-level apartment construction in infill areas. And some of these areas have been bereft of the factors that the Index shows achieves high levels of amenity: within walking distance to rail or priority light rail and bus routes that connect to employment locations; within walking distance to a plentiful supply of local shops and services; well-connected and safe walking and cycling routes; and a range of different residential options that help create a vibrant social mix of different family types.

I think the Index helpfully shows that density is just part of the story. The Index is comprised of twenty separate measures- and many of these are not at all reliant on densification. As I’ve shown above, we cannot simply assume that areas of high density automatically generate liveable and sustainable outcomes. There are simply too many factors at play to make this conclusion.

Dr Michael Grosvenor, Principal MGC

Welcome to our blog...

We have a passion for research that tells a story, that can be presented visually, that brings about change and improves organisations. And we hope these resources help you know the times.

Our Social Media Sites

Facebook | McCrindle Research Social Media YouTube | McCrindle Research Social Media Twitter | McCrindle Research Social Media Flickr | McCrindle Research Social Media Pinterest | McCrindle Research Social Media Google Plus | McCrindle Research Social Media LinkedIn | McCrindle Research Social Media Mark McCrindle Slideshare

Last 150 Articles


Research Executive mover and shaker moderators guide divorce rate global generations suburbs interactive events travel hello fresh personalities world youth day friends hornsby speaker millenials authenticity marriages australia infographics organisations New Zealand wealth inequality property market TED talk debate average aussie hills shire brisbane Bathburst networking survey design skills belief education research safe Australian Trends Crime Rates wage buildings food insecurity PSI mining boom australian brand experience McCridle volunteers Financial Planning Association poor non profit English internships 10 years school students dreams REIV Conference group session workforce intern dessert 1975 leader social sentiments shopping centre moreton bay Hornsby Shire Council coffee lovers graphs census fail DESTEL professional development social life religion population healthy future menai forum dreaming states technology ideas Research Director goal keynote speaker 40 million sydney hills schools students home grandparents royal influence local communities princess charlotte typical australian spend future proofing researcher work mates cancelling event focus group weekly earnings darwin US optus my business awards young australians sector teacher summer royal baby energy Black Friday twentyseventeen market research earning gig The ABC of XYZ mccrinlde socialites screenage investment NEETs vegemite daily commute qualitative research global ageing population the average aussie snapshot Hunter Valley victoria "know the times" selfie entrepreneur demographer presentation VET local 24 million mobile trends of 2017 presentations 2020 state Netflix christianity equip Vocational education giving collaboration population map baby boom entertainment australian communities forum house GPO social enquiry the great screenage Australian Dream Australian Population research pack high density apartments millennials the hills shire Northern Territory mccrindle tea future of shopping neutral bay royal teaching urban living friendship Christchurch future-proof donate rent group ashley mckenzie study World Water Day new office poker master entrepreneurial commuters trends of 2016 23 million politics Channel Seven innovative communications cash data visualisation affordability jobs geomapping culture internet Real Estate Institute of Victoria apartments Melbourne Aussies impact annual income financial future personal growth media release donation consumer financial residents Deaths proactive list sector wide cost hobart new york times Australian community trends in depth interviews stay home social commentary child care income capital cities ABS not for profit WA earn New Zeland repayments pyrmont huffington post domestic Kiwi office opening sydneysider #censusfail sun brands employers Word Up quote trend work-life Geoff Brailey cars media activity clothing story digital cooking micro apartments social shifts bureau Tuesday Trends TEDx staying in focus groups litter forecasting area insights weather high density living social trends Christmas lunch business performance data analyst gig economy financial dreams infographic wall business urban taskforce 2016 census results renting monarchy younger generations etiquette government Australian communities Social Trend household Australia Day sydney metro responsive anzac year 7 thrive keynote ease of travel celebration student workshop optus house price Maxim Accounting generational trends high density Mark McCrindle in the media newspaper nfp sustainable work from home census 2016 commute shbc community event forecast going out Lower Hunter Region click trends baby futurist education future community rise of local suburban living Andrew Duffin census employmer life communities global financial crisis research data education divorce pharmacy Elderslie-Harrington park Generation X professional experience resilience wealth national wealth faith Skilling food royal family ACF17 the australian dream Channel 7 professional services daily telegraph conferences teleworking research on coffee Myth bondi visualisation SA society Caregiver winter average Australian tableau 2016 What is food insecurity? Merry Christmas employmee organisational culture christmas casual CBD townhouses australian community trends report rental stress NFP event city money Valentine’s Day tea australian social research builders The Daily Edition vegetarian ageing prince george product workplace food bank contiki average sydneysider ACF 2016 Gen Y education future report criminal survey sydneysiders storytelling generation sydney speaker relational 2015 gender social researchers women Aussie cancelling plans careers know the times young people millionth online economy HSC Love Territory identity kate middleton post rationalism James Ward South Australia fears ashley fell 2012 crows nest urban home ownership the lucky country optimistic publication public transport christian children DIY SMSF employment Cobbitty-Leppington change trends analyst gen alpha school satisfaction middle class TED ACF2017 mccrindle research tertiary education learn January 26th event earnings resource living demographic transformations investor Western Australia SRE potts point Sydney Hills Business Chamber research report Financial Planning Association of Australia Births micro data Christmas season aged care puzzle speajer urban living index goals emerging generations sunny days eliane pharmacies house prices volunteer CPI research services Sydney Work place population growth transport growth case study wolloomooloo Wagga Wagga marriage australians staying home more tv aussie culture community engagement cost of living internship consumerism conference presentation cancel plans Real Estate social change screenagers village demographic results offenders follow NBRS Architecture gen z sunburnt country google for education innovation communication Res Vis trades logan teachers australian communities trends report relevant speakers pack youth unemployment financial planning 2017 baby name medicine demographic trends future manly define speakers learning charity Black Friday in Australia Mount Annan-Currant Hill insight narcissism ultimo Population Clock Black Friday Sales cloudy days statistics 1980 Charlotte demographics financial fears System's Architect shifts shopping mythbusters video Australians aged care housing affordability changing face of sydney supply and demand 2016 census chairty Australian Census home owner mother's day future of education cultural diversity workplace culture Duchess of Cambridge spirituality 1994 wealth and income unaffordable motivate baby name trends world media commentary education sector ferry stats cica Australian Bureau of Statistics care support teach volunteering data growth of sydney digital economy Wellington salary Australian Communities Trends baby names australia report Australia street future proof baby names report Assistant Store Manager Australian demographics affordable Queensland the hills educhat travelling leadership growing population eliane miles fresh outsourcing global retail brand Retail mentor marrickville finance students australian real estate father's day balance choice workers VIC volunteering long weekend program local community learning styles engagement emerging trends language house price rise Tuesday Trend society trends VET sector gold coast social research mccrindle in the media New South Wales toys customer Australian Home public speaker hopes meals cartodb deloitte Performance Sentiment Index Northern Beaches Christian School slideshare renter of the future perth commuting high school social analyst coffee housing easter social issues men Macquarie University thought leadership environmental scanning Wodonga ACT Report tuesday suburb names owning a home paying to work panel FPA not-for-profit parents Scouts tattoos research 2014 Royals generations cultural diveristy Australian Families property infographic award baby names analysis train showreel mccrindle car social commentator hills staff wealth distribution apartment sector wide study bus national crime rates grave decision award winner online shopping Education Future Forum mortgage not for profit research news church property price megatrends socialising 2013 university degree ethnography media Jura Australia entrepreneurs of today capital city in the media FOMO generation Z rich economic conference speaker NBRS office space retirement Australian schools environment NT communicate small business population milestone demography wages couple report greatness unemployment lalor park year 12 learner dare to dream Australia Day 2017 winter blues Gen X public holiday faux-cilising plans facts families mateship alpha increasing densification family meetings Mark McCrindle lifestyle housing trends Jura Coffee social researcher census data challenge Generation Y dream ipswich JOMO debt Engineering Manager Financial Planning Week low density sydneycity crime career work Northern Beaches REIV National Conference wedding sports who is generation z Sydney’s south west households Willowdale participants educated housing market trend tuesday hunger social lives conference mythbusting rule keeper NSW curiosity professional presenters faux-cilise financial independence McCrindle Speakers business index omnibus social impact housing growth the changing face of social media future of work investing Northern beaches Event live the dream culturally diverse youth professional speaker public speaking ACF real land of the middle class Do It Yourself woolworths priorities leadership workshop census results charities TDE recap holiday February 16 training waverton cold research visualisation seasons EFF engage Canberra shopper's pick Sydney population IT Specialists national private wealth rising house prices university Tasmania Kirsten Brewer happiness breakfast SMART marketing tips baby boomers emerging technologies jobs of the future Hills Shire Council sydney event Lower Hunter ACT Sydney keynote speaker acf15 google schools office generation alpha faux-ciliser overcast wealth and income distribution holidays Queensland: QLD easy rider parenting 1968 Business analysis social analysis wellbeing visual baby name predictions Christmas presents TAS water norwest rain blaxland 24,000,000 purpose Adelaide budget school collaborative